Coupon IconDeals
tracking-pixeltracking-pixel

Storage in Bay Shore, NY

1 - 30 of 78 Storage Facilities in Bay Shore, NY

Sort By:
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage NY Farmingdale Bi County Blvd
Trusted Partner Badge
Trusted Partner Facility
Top-rated facility with exceptional service

9.5 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage NY Farmingdale Bi County Blvd

505 Bi County Boulevard, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

5' x 5'
Deal
$57.00$34.20
5' x 10'
Deal
$70.00$42.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$150.00$90.00
View all units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - Holbrook - 640 Broadway Avenue

9.9 miles away

4.9(7)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Holbrook - 640 Broadway Avenue

640 Broadway Avenue, Holbrook, NY, 11741

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10'
Deal
$122.00$73.20
10' x 10'
Deal
$224.00$134.40
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4281 - Bay Shore - Howells Rd

1.6 miles away

4.8(2)

Extra Space Storage - 4281 - Bay Shore - Howells Rd

225 Howells Road, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

5' x 5'
$85.00$80.00
5' x 10'
$59.00$55.00
10' x 10'
$99.00$93.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunrise Highway

11.3 miles away

4.7(30)

Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunrise Highway

601 W Sunrise Highway, Patchogue, NY, 11772

5' x 5'
Deal
$64.00$48.00
5' x 10'3 Left
$85.00$64.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$176.00$132.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of SecureSpace Self Storage Deer Park

4.6 miles away

SecureSpace Self Storage Deer Park

999 Long Island Avenue, Deer Park, NY, 11729

5' x 5'
Deal
2 Left
$62.00
5' x 10'
Deal
1 Left
$49.00
10' x 10'
Deal
3 Left
$95.00
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3197 - Bay Shore - Saxon Ave

1.2 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 3197 - Bay Shore - Saxon Ave

110 Saxon Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

5' x 5'
$66.00$63.00
10' x 5'
$112.00$106.00
10' x 10'
$216.00$206.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Lindenhurst - 1070 Route 109

7.9 miles away

3.5(1)

Public Storage - Lindenhurst - 1070 Route 109

1070 Route 109, Lindenhurst, NY, 11757

5' x 5'
Deal
2 Left
$71.00$53.00
10' x 5'
Deal
2 Left
$73.00$55.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$118.00$89.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7929 - Bohemia - Lakeland Ave

8 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 7929 - Bohemia - Lakeland Ave

1590 Lakeland Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

5' x 5'
$34.00$33.00
5' x 10'
Deal
$53.00$50.00
10' x 10'
$172.00$164.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon Ave

1.2 miles away

4.7(14)

Public Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon Ave

122 Saxon Ave, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10'
Deal
$127.00$95.00
10' x 10'
Deal
1 Left
$195.00$150.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Prime Storage - Central Islip

4.6 miles away

3.8(4)

Prime Storage - Central Islip

625 Eastview Drive, Central Islip, NY, 11722

5' x 5'2 Left
$82.00$79.00
10' x 5'
Deal
$150.00$121.00
10' x 10'
$221.00$145.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 6965 - Copiague - Sunrise Hwy

8.3 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 6965 - Copiague - Sunrise Hwy

1550 Sunrise Highway, Copiague, NY, 11726

5' x 5'
$23.00
10' x 5'
$39.00
10' x 10'
$123.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - West Babylon - 821 Sunrise Hwy

4.8 miles away

4.9(9)

Public Storage - West Babylon - 821 Sunrise Hwy

821 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY, 11704

5' x 5'1 Left
$59.00$47.00
5' x 10'2 Left
$65.00$49.00
10' x 10'1 Left
$152.00$114.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nesconset Hwy

9.9 miles away

4.7(12)

Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nesconset Hwy

770 Nesconset Hwy, Nesconset, NY, 11767

5' x 5'
Deal
$65.00$61.00
5' x 10'
Deal
$77.00$58.00
10' x 10'
Deal
1 Left
$151.00$113.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Farmingville - 951 HorseBlock Road

13.8 miles away

4.8(24)

Public Storage - Farmingville - 951 HorseBlock Road

951 HorseBlock Road, Farmingville, NY, 11738

5' x 5'
Deal
$47.00$35.00
5' x 10'
$136.00$102.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$247.00$185.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Hauppauge - 745 Old Willets Path

5.8 miles away

5.0(2)

Public Storage - Hauppauge - 745 Old Willets Path

745 Old Willets Path, Hauppauge, NY, 11788

5' x 5'
Deal
3 Left
$71.00$53.00
5' x 10'
Deal
$77.00$58.00
10' x 10'
Deal
1 Left
$223.00$179.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Farmingdale - 305 Del Dr

9.5 miles away

4.7(29)

Public Storage - Farmingdale - 305 Del Dr

305 Del Dr, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

5' x 5'
Deal
$40.00$30.00
5' x 10'
$60.00$45.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$186.00$117.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage NY Saint James Middle Country Rd

10.1 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage NY Saint James Middle Country Rd

514 Middle Country Road, Saint James, NY, 11780

5' x 5'
Deal
$60.00$45.00
5' x 10'
Deal
$164.00$98.40
10' x 10'
Deal
$267.00$160.20
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Hicksville - 800 S Oyster Bay Rd

13.6 miles away

4.8(25)

Public Storage - Hicksville - 800 S Oyster Bay Rd

800 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY, 11801

5' x 5'
$53.00$40.00
5' x 10'
$72.00$67.00
10' x 10'
$204.00$169.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Public Storage - Huntington Station - 670 E Jericho Tpke

10.5 miles away

5.0(1)

Public Storage - Huntington Station - 670 E Jericho Tpke

670 E Jericho Tpke, Huntington Station, NY, 11746

5' x 5'2 Left
$34.00$26.00
5' x 10'
Deal
3 Left
$129.00$97.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$153.00$115.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of StorQuest - Deer Park / Grand

3.8 miles away

4.7(12)

StorQuest - Deer Park / Grand

960 Grand Boulevard, Deer Park, NY, 11729

5' x 5'
Deal
$35.00
5' x 10'1 Left
$58.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$99.00
View all units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - NY Deer Park Long Island Avenue

4.6 miles away

4.5(2)

CubeSmart Self Storage - NY Deer Park Long Island Avenue

999 Long Island Avenue, Deer Park, NY, 11729

5' x 5'
Deal
$91.00$54.60
5' x 10'
Deal
$119.00$71.40
10' x 10'
Deal
$216.00$129.60
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0674 - Hauppauge - Old Willets Path

5.9 miles away

5.0(2)

Extra Space Storage - 0674 - Hauppauge - Old Willets Path

730 Old Willets Path, Hauppauge, NY, 11788

5' x 5'
$38.00$36.00
5' x 10'
$71.00$68.00
10' x 10'
$161.00$153.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units

3.9 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 7386 - North Babylon - Deer Park Rd

1251 Deer Park Avenue, North Babylon, NY, 11703

5' x 5'
$54.00
5' x 10'
$64.00
10' x 10'
$158.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4167 - Islip - Moffitt Blvd

1.8 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 4167 - Islip - Moffitt Blvd

260 Moffitt Boulevard, Islip, NY, 11751

5' x 5'
$52.00$49.00
10' x 5'
$89.00$84.00
10' x 10'
$134.00$128.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave

3.1 miles away

5.0(4)

Extra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave

1775 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

5' x 5'
$40.00$38.00
5' x 10'
$71.00$67.00
10' x 10'
$116.00$111.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - North Babylon

3.9 miles away

4.6(14)

CubeSmart Self Storage - North Babylon

240 Bay Shore Road, North Babylon, NY, 11703

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10'
Deal
$167.00$100.20
10' x 10'
Deal
$107.00$80.25
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7995 - Huntington Station - 403 Oakwood Rd

12.5 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 7995 - Huntington Station - 403 Oakwood Rd

403 Oakwood Road, Huntington Station, NY, 11746

5' x 5'
$35.00$33.00
5' x 10'
Deal
$47.00$44.00
10' x 10'
Deal
$103.00$97.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 6992 - Oakdale - Montauk Hwy

5.6 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 6992 - Oakdale - Montauk Hwy

1625 Montauk Highway, Oakdale, NY, 11769

4' x 4'
$44.00$42.00

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'
$200.00$188.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7432 - Deer Park - Acorn St

5.7 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 7432 - Deer Park - Acorn St

541 Acorn Street, Deer Park, NY, 11729

5' x 5'
$48.00$46.00
5' x 10'
$76.00$72.00
10' x 10'
$104.00$99.00
Online Move-In Available
View all units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - NY Bethpage Stewart

12.7 miles away

4.7(15)

CubeSmart Self Storage - NY Bethpage Stewart

909 Stewart Avenue, Bethpage, NY, 11714

5' x 5'
Deal
$54.00$40.50
5' x 10'
Deal
$124.00$74.40
10' x 10'
Deal
$183.00$137.25
View all units

Storage prices in Bay Shore, NY

Prices vary by unit size and amenities. Compare facilities in Bay Shore to find the right unit.

Average Monthly Price by Storage Unit Size in Bay Shore, NY

Based on 41 storage units in Bay Shore.

$100.73

ReducedToUp$10.02
Compared to last month

Cheapest Storage in Bay Shore, NY

  • sizeIcon

    Cheapest 5x10 storage in Bay Shore, NY

    $26.00$85.27
    DetailsArrow
    priceTag$59.27 Below average unit priceExtra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave
  • sizeIcon

    Cheapest 10x10 storage in Bay Shore, NY

    $66.00$122.53
    DetailsArrow
    priceTag$56.53 Below average unit priceExtra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave
  • sizeIcon

    Cheapest 10x15 storage in Bay Shore, NY

    $123.00$191.94
    DetailsArrow
    priceTag$68.94 Below average unit priceExtra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave
  • sizeIcon

    Cheapest 10x20 storage in Bay Shore, NY

    $173.00$239.64
    DetailsArrow
    priceTag$66.64 Below average unit pricePublic Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon Ave
Average prices last updated on 01-01-2026.

Average Price by Storage Unit Size in Bay Shore, NY

Find online move-in rates and specials like first month half off and first month FREE at select Bay Shore, New York storage facilities. Below are the average monthly storage unit prices in Bay Shore, New York for the most common storage unit sizes.

Unit SizeAverage PriceLowest Price
5' x 5'$60.29$34.00
5' x 10'$85.27$26.00
10' x 10'$122.53$66.00
10' x 15'$191.94$123.00
10' x 20'$239.64$173.00

The overall average price of a self-storage unit booked in Bay Shore, New York over the past 180 days is $103.88.

Data for the cheapest self-storage unit is updated every 15 minutes.

SpareFoot customer reviews

SpareFoot has a 4.3 out of 5 star rating from over 41,000 customer reviews on Trustpilot. See what some of our over one million customers say about us.

THE BEST service on the phone I've had

I looked myself for hours trying to find a storage for my RV and then called SpareFoot and they found me two great RV spots quickly that were exactly within my criteria. Oscar who helped me was absolutely the best customer care person I have ever dealt with period. 5 stars well deserved!

MP by mark p

Rented unit in 25 minutes

Rented unit in 25 minutes, manager was kind and made sure to provide all info.

AL by Ariadna Lester

Very nice friendly easy reservation…

Very nice friendly easy reservation assistant

BW by bonita walker

Helpful Resources

How Does Self-Storage Work?

First time renting self-storage? Read how it works here.

Storage Unit Size Guide

Find out what size storage unit you need.

Storage Unit Amenities

From climate control to 24-hour access, decide which features you need.

Storage Unit Safety & Security

Learn how storage facilities keep your belongings safe.

Frequently asked questions about storage in Bay Shore, New York

Is climate control storage necessary in Bay Shore, NY?

Climate controlled storage is necessary in Bay Shore if you're planning to store sensitive items like wood furniture, electronics, paper documents and heirlooms or sentimental items. These items might be subject to damage in extreme heat or cold temperatures and high humidity levels. Climate controlled storage units are typically kept between 50 and 80 degrees year round with humidity control.

Where can I find commercial storage for my business near Bay Shore, NY?

To easily find commercial storage in Bay Shore, NY look for storage facilities that either specifically advertise this option, or have storage units with amenities like climate control, 24-hour access, drive-up access and electrical sockets.

How much is a 10x10 storage unit in Bay Shore, NY?

A 10x10 storage unit in Bay Shore, NY costs $122.53 per month. Some unit amenities, like 24 hour access, may increase the monthly price.

What is the smallest storage unit I can rent in Bay Shore, NY?

Storage lockers are technically the smallest storage unit size in Bay Shore, NY, but these units look more like a cabinet than a standard storage unit. A 5x5 unit is the smallest standard storage unit and much more popular with renters than a storage locker. You can learn more about each unit size from our self storage size guide.

How much is a storage unit per month in Bay Shore?

On average, storage units in Bay Shore, NY cost $103.88 per month. Prices vary depending on the unit size you rent and the amenities you choose, like climate control.

Browse Bay Shore Storage by Amenity

Browse Bay Shore Storage by Type

Browse Bay Shore Storage by Unit Size

Storage in nearby cities

Can't decide? Let SpareFoot help you choose.
Phone iconNeed Help?